St Catherine's College Rowing Society
President: Colin Smith
Vice Presidents: Neil Chugani, Richard Peters, Sir Matthew Pinsent CBE, Ben Sylvester, Zoe de Toledo, Andrew Triggs Hodge OBE.
[Prev]

Newsletter#2, Hilary Term, 2023 (18th March)

[Next]

[PDF version]

Contents

Links

St Catherine's College
Oxford University Rowing Clubs
St Catherine's College Boat Club
St Catherine's Rowing Society

In this issue ...

Over the past few years our 1st VIIIs have generally progressed upwards, or at least not more than a place or two downwards, so I suppose it was only a time before gravity reasserted itself with a bump. Or two. At least both the men's and women's boats went down together, which avoided any of those awkward situations at the Rowing Society dinner.

Now, having had a couple of weeks in which to relax back into to normal student life, the Captains provide their reports.

Boat Race crews have been announced and we have three students lining up in the Oxford boats over the next seven days: Zac Abel in the men's lightweights (racing on 20th March, i.e., Monday), Helen Nielsen-Scott in Osiris and Freddy Orpin in the OUBC Blue Boat, both on 26th March (next weekend). This year I thought I'd apply a slightly more formal analysis to the results of the various private fixtures undertaken by all the boat races crews to try and work out their relative speeds. If you don't want to know the results — look away before you get to the last page of this newsletter.

The one that got away. The Men's 2nd Torpid under a certain amount of pressure from New College II as they exit the Gut on the Friday. However, on that occasion they managed to row over.

M2

Results

Isis Winter League D 5th February

80 crews raced
1st 4:26.0 Wolfson A 1st/41 M8
9th 4:59.0 St Catz A 9th/41 M8
24th 5:28.0 Lincoln A 1st/34 W8
28th 5:38.5 St Catz B 27th/41 M8
36th 5:47.5 St Catz A 5th/34 W8
74th 6:47.5 St Catz B 30th/34 W8

Rowing On 17th February

26/33 Women's crews to qualify
1st 3:11.5 Keble II
9th 3:25.0 St Catherine's II
26th 3:49.0 Christ Church III

Torpids 22–25th February
Wed Thu Fri Sat Finish

Men's I −1 −2 −2 −1 9th Div I
Women's I −3 −2 −2 −2 5th Div IV
Men's II −4 −1 = −4 6th Div IV
Women's II = +2 −1 −1 4th Div VI

Bumps Charts

St Catherine's Torpids

Men's 1st Torpid
B Alexander Scruton
2 Noah Rice
3 Thomas Aston
4 Cameron Doyle1
5 Matthew Jackson
6 Thomas Lim
7 Hamza Ahmad
S Lachlan Stewart
C Sophie Marchent2
1 Thomas Long (Wed)
2 Eugenio Vecchi (Sat)
Men's 2nd Torpid
B Eugenio Vecchi
2 Alex Colby
3 Flynn Hallman3
4 Yousself El-Toukhy
5 Robert Lennon
6 Archie Moss4
7 Timothy Kilbey5
S James Farmborough
C Lachlan Stewart
3 Angus Millard (Fri)
4 Max Cowan (Sat)
5 Tom Wagstaff (Thu/Fri)
Women's 1st Torpid
B Cecilia Catmur
2 Freya Waterworth
3 Elizabeth Rees1
4 Brooke Reese2
5 Brittany O'Duffy
6 Kellie Everett
7 Lucinda Harden
S Emma Coakley
C Ben Blackburn
1 Ilayda Karadag (Fri/Sat)
2 Cecilia Schultz (Fri/Sat)
Women's 2nd Torpid
B Alaina Flory3
2 Lucia Pyne4
3 Siyu Li5
4 Leiyan Wei6
5 Reem Alnuaimi7
6 Emma O'Donnell8
7 Whitney Deng9
S Emma Halliday
C Ilayda Karadaga
3 Paula To (Thu)
4 Divya Agarwal (Thu)
5 Paula To (Thu)
6 Illayda Karadag (Thu)
7 Maria Villamil (Thu)
7 Felice Wallner (Fri)
8 Divya Agarwal (Sat)
9 Felice Wallner (Fri)
a Rowan Nicholls (Thu)
Men's Coach: Laurence Whitely Women's Coach: Rowan Nicholls

Women's Boat Club

Emma Coakley, Women's Co-Captain

Hilary term got off to a rocky start with red flag preventing any on water training. Conditions did eventually improve, but this left us with very little time to prepare before IWL D. Despite this, we managed to field two boats in this race, with W1 obtaining a strong result of 5th. Two weeks later, in Rowing On, W2 received an equally impressive result, qualifying in 9th place out of 33 crews.

Unfortunately, this success did not last, with Torpids proving to be a challenging week. W1 fell nine places on the river, and sustained substantial damage to their rudder on the second day, rendering the boat unusable for the rest of the week. W2 were frustrated to have their several of their races cut short by klaxons, but despite this managed to bump Hertford II, and finished the week only one place lower overall.

Although these were clearly not the results we would have wished for, there are still many reasons to take pride in our performance. The progress made by both crews in a short space of time has been undeniable, with only two members of W1 having any previous experience in Torpids, and all of W2 having learned to row at the start of this academic year. This rapid progress, combined with the invaluable experience gained during Torpids means we are hopeful of mounting a strong comeback during Summer Eights.

The Women's 2nd Torpid. Hang on ... is bow wearing 'mouse' ears?

W2

However, we know that significant work will be required in order to achieve this. For this reason, the last few weeks of term involved tank sessions to improve technique, and a series of productive outings, including one in which we rowed through Iffley and Sandford locks. This lock trip was incredibly beneficial, so we aim to be able to repeat this early in Trinity term, in the hope that the extended time on the water gives each boat more chance to come together as a crew, something which we felt was lacking this Torpids.

The Women's 1st Torpid on the Friday

W1

Men's Boat Club

Lachlan Stewart, Men's Co-Captain

Hilary Term was a slightly challenging one for SCCBC. The term started off with the Isis flooded and deep into red flag territory, so the squad was confined to spending hours in the gym, losing much-needed water time but building up to a solid level of fitness. A weekend trip to Dorney Lake was attempted, only to be thwarted at the last minute by the sudden descent of thick fog. Thankfully, however, once the rains abated the river dropped quickly, and we were able to start getting crews out on the water 3 weeks before Torpids.

Unfortunately, Torpids didn't exactly go to plan. A fairly inexperienced squad that was a bit short on numbers definitely felt the impact of nearly a month's worth of lost water time across the end of Michaelmas and start of Hilary, and, when combined with already very lofty starting positions for both M1 and M2 (starting 3rd on the river and 9th in division 3 respectively) and a number of crews around us having notably strong years, this all resulted in a disappointing outcome. What cannot be faulted is the effort put in and determination shown by every member of both crews, with our highlight of the week being an incredibly gutsy row-over on the Friday by M2, chased closely by New College II who had overlap for the last 200 metres or so. Nevertheless, a difficult week for SCCBC but there's a lot to learn, and with a very large proportion of the M1 likely to be around next year we're hopeful that we can rapidly regain the positions we lost.

The Men's 1st Torpid on the Saturday

M1

Looking ahead to the immediate future, the squad is very much looking forward to a training camp in Italy before the start of Trinity, where, fuelled by excellent food, no doubt some big steps will be made both technically and physiologically. Beyond that, we're also in the fortunate position of expecting the influx of a significant number of very experienced athletes into the squad for Trinity term, bolstering our stocks and hopefully contributing to a more successful Summer Eights.

University Crews

As part of the build-up to the Boat Race, the Oxford and Cambridge crews arrange side-by-side fixtures on the Tideway against a variety of clubs, usually carefully chosen so that they don't both race the same opponents too close together because, well, that would give too much away. On the other hand, their opponents regularly participate in various Head races which allows additional cross-comparison, the latest being this afternoon's Tideway Head of the River Race.

From the various publicly available results I've compiled a list of 45 men's and 51 women's crew-on-crew match-ups, applied some maths (a branch of statistics called 'Estimation Theory' if you really need to know) and come up with the following speeds, expressed in seconds/minute, relative to the Oxford Blue Boats.

But first, some caveats. I'm well aware that crew line-ups change from week to week, particularly the match-race opponents; there are a couple of 'tuning' parameters in the algorithm; and I've had to use some judgement to convert verdicts given in lengths into seconds/minute. But I have run a check for anomalous results, and only one was (just) outside the 2σ range, so not enough to justify its removal (and, in any, didn't involve any Boat Race crews). I've also allowed for 'evolution' in the sense of giving less weight to earlier results.

So, after all that analysis, I conclude that the Oxford men's and women's Blue Boats are, within the error bars, almost exactly the same speed as their Cambridge counterparts; I predict two very painful Blue Boat races. For the reserve crews, though, Oxford seem to have a clearer advantage (after the Fours Head last November I thought the opposite would be true). I've found relatively few results for the lightweight crews, but the Cambridge men's lightweights do actually appear to be faster than Goldie, so I fear for the Oxford men (although the only result I have for them is from Quintin Head back on 19th January).

men
women

Apart from the Oxford and Cambridge boats, the other crews involved were Oxford Brookes (OBU), Leander, University of London (UL), Molesey, Imperial College, Thames (Women) and a random crew of Dutch internationals who raced Cambridge.

Oxford Brookes A won the (men's) Head of the River Race today, with Leander A second and OBU B third, so OUBC and CUBC can both reasonably claim to be in the top 4 club crews in the country.

Leander crews filled the top two places in the Women's Head a few weeks ago but I gather the top boat was a one-off collection of GB squad rowers so I've taken the second crew as the Leander A that has been racing (and beating) the Oxford and Cambridge Women's Blue Boats. Brookes' A crew were third then, but are given a faster speed than Leander A largely on the basis of beating the Oxford and Cambridge crews by larger distances, and the Brookes' B crew also appear faster than either. So among club crews, both women's Blue Boats probably rate 3rd–7th in the country at the moment (along with Leander B and the University of London).

Coming Up ...

There will be reports on the Boat Races, which I remind you are on Monday for the Lightweights (live on YouTube), and next Saturday for the other crews (I expect the BBC have got that covered).

Over the Easter break the Boat Club will be off to their regular training camp at Lago di Monate in northern Italy, so I'm hoping for at least a good photo for the next newsletter.

There's a chance that crews may come back fired up to race in the City Bumps, right at the start of term — this year in VIIIs rather than IVs — in which case I'll cover that, as well as the usual details and prospects for Eights.

Anu Dudhia

Diary

20 Mar 2023 Lightweight Boat Races
26 Mar 2023 The Boat Races
23 Apr 2023 City Bumps
24–27 May 2023 Eights
24 Jun 2023 Gaudy (M.1993–2002)